All Things Digital

Skip to main content.

MediaMemo

Jason Calacanis Tries Turning Mahalo Into a Wikipedia That Pays

mahalo-logo2Jason Calacanis’ Mahalo is getting a two-part makeover.

There’s a visual overhaul for the search engine,  which involves cramming a lot more stuff on each results page. This is becoming standard operating practice on the Web, both because it offers readers a lot more stuff, and because it seems to help improve search engine rankings. (You can see the before and after pages at the bottom of this post.)

The other change isn’t as easy to see, but it’s a big change for Calacanis, who originally envisioned his company as “human-powered search engine,” where his employees would build out results pages one at a time.

But now he’s hoping to get Mahalo users to do the work, Wikipedia-style, with a twist–he’ll pay them.

The pitch: Calacanis will offer users the chance to “own” a results page, and split any advertising revenue the page generates, primarily via Google (GOOG) AdSense. He’ll be paying users with “Mahalo bucks,” which cash out at 75 cents on the dollar, so users are really keeping 37.5 percent of each dollar their page generates.

Calacanis says some of his pages are generating up to $10,000 a year, but most will make far less. Will that be enough to encourage people to build and maintain Web pages on a piecework basis?

He is betting it will: Right now Calacanis employs about 50 people to make his results pages, but he says that over time, that number will shrink to a couple dozen editors who will oversee “hundreds” of workers: “We think this will become a half-time to full-time job for a large number of out-of-work people.”

Calacanis says the move isn’t designed to save him money, since he’ll be carving out a chunk of his ad revenue to pay his people. He’s raised $20 million and says that will last him four to five years, thanks in part to cuts he made last fall; he predicts he’ll be breaking even within a year.

Here are the before and after screenshots:

Mahalo 1.0
bob-dylan-mahalo-10

Mahalo 2.0
bob-dylan-mahalo-20

We’ve launched a new commenting tool, Disqus. For the full story on all of its functionality, click here. To begin commenting right away, you can log in below using Facebook Connect or Disqus—you can also log in using an existing AllThingsD account. Learn more about how Disqus collects and uses information in connection with the comments tool.
  • Bjorn Tipling
    This has been tried by Squidoo. It's also similar to knol.
  • Dave Esmo
    Bah. Another act of desperation on the behalf of Mahalo/Calacanis.

    Look how just few days ago, Calacanis was caught misapropriating other site's content: blog.fluther.com/blog/2009/06/01/an-open-letter-to-jason-calacanis/

    This will be just another content theft site but on a large scale.

    And it will FAIL!
  • Peter: "Calacanis says some of his pages are generating up to $10,000 a year, but most will make far less. Will that be enough to encourage people to build and maintain Web pages on a piecework basis?" You should dig into what the actual distribution of keyword query frequency is. My hunch, if the major search engines are any indication, is that disproportionately few keywords drive the vast majority of traffic (by a longshot). Which would probably translate into a similarly distributed frequency of visits to member-owned search pages. On one hand, this validates the potential of a human-powered search engine, in that there's a lot of traffic goes to finite number of pages. But it also questions the real money-making potential for users. And "users are really keeping 37.5 percent of each dollar their page generates"? But how much is Google Adsense keeping from the original split? I'm not knocking Mahalo, and perhaps this model will succeed. But these were my initial questions.
  • Gregory Kohs
    Interesting. I like Jason and all, but it's disappointing that he's giving dedicated maintenance workers only 50% of their "claimed" page's ad revenues. Revenue sharing for content has been done before (Squidoo, Helium come to mind), but they always take a hefty cut of the action away from the creator.

    Over on MyWikiBiz, for over two years, the volunteer editors can claim a page about any legal entity, maintain it, and keep 100% of the ad revenues within their content.

    MyWikiBiz draws only from the ad revenue generated by the thin footer of text-link ads at the bottom of every page. The top editors are pulling down about $30-$50 per month from ads.
  • The original premise & promise of Mahalo was that it would employ human judgment to clear away all the garbage in search engine results and give you only the top quality results you need. Now it jams as much info into a page as possible so that it SEOs well, and pays writers and editors a pittance, motivating them to create quick shoddy work. I understand the economics, but will any intelligent user really want to use this product ? There is a large role in the Internet's future for well-curated content that clears away all the clutter and directs users only to credible and comprehensive resources; it looks like Mahalo has veered off that road.
  • joshua palau
    Um...wasn't this the About.com model?
blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest MediaMemo Videos

More Videos »

About Peter

Peter Kafka has been covering media and technology since 1997, when he joined the staff of Forbes magazine. Most recently, he has been the managing editor of the tech and media Web site, Silicon Alley Insider. Read more »

Send an Anonymous Tip »

Ethics Statement

Here is a statement of my ethics and coverage policies. It is more than most of you want to know, but, in the age of suspicion of the media, I am laying it all out.

Read more »